{
 "dataset": "디자인 심판 유형별·연도별 인용률 통계",
 "publisher": "특허사무소 소담 (Sodam IP)",
 "author_reviewer": "여인재 변리사",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.ko)",
 "attribution": "특허사무소 소담, https://sodamip.com/",
 "snapshot_date": "2026-09-22",
 "data_cutoff": "2026-09-17",
 "update_cycle": "continuous; full dataset snapshot when source corpus is refreshed",
 "source_corpus": "특허심판원 심결문 (집계 통계, 개별 사건 식별정보 없음)",
 "canonical_article": "https://sodamip.com/blog/2026/05/22/design-invalidity-acceptance-rate-2073cases/",
 "notes": "merit_total = 인용+일부인용+기각 (각하·취하 제외). acceptance_rate(%) = (인용+일부인용)/merit_total.",
 "revision": "2026-09-22 신규 심결·판결 반영 및 기존 사건 분류 보완",
 "supersedes": "https://sodamip.com/data/design_acceptance_rate_20260920.json",
 "methodology_note": "일부인용은 인용률에 포함하며 각하·취하 등은 본안 인용률에서 제외합니다. 검수된 중복 수록과 비상표 기록은 집계에서 제외하고 원시 기록은 보존합니다. 취소판결 후 재심결은 원문 사건번호를 보존하며, 병합 심결은 사건번호 단위로 집계합니다. 심리기간은 접수연도에 따른 근사치입니다.",
 "aggregation_exclusions": {
  "field": "디자인",
  "excluded_count": 0,
  "reasons": [],
  "note": "집계 제외 원장의 기존 제외 기록을 유지하며 원시 기록은 보존합니다."
 },
 "stats": {
  "meta": {
   "field": "디자인",
   "stat_type": "acceptance_rate",
   "generated_at": "2026-09-22T23:24:30.230819",
   "total_records": 4757
  },
  "data": {
   "by_year": {
    "2010": {
     "accepted": 214,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 75,
     "dismissed": 22,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 4,
     "merit_total": 289,
     "total": 315,
     "acceptance_rate": 74.0
    },
    "2011": {
     "accepted": 243,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 120,
     "dismissed": 34,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 8,
     "merit_total": 363,
     "total": 405,
     "acceptance_rate": 66.9
    },
    "2012": {
     "accepted": 218,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 108,
     "dismissed": 18,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 2,
     "merit_total": 326,
     "total": 346,
     "acceptance_rate": 66.9
    },
    "2013": {
     "accepted": 181,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 128,
     "dismissed": 20,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 4,
     "merit_total": 309,
     "total": 333,
     "acceptance_rate": 58.6
    },
    "2014": {
     "accepted": 224,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 77,
     "dismissed": 17,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 7,
     "merit_total": 301,
     "total": 325,
     "acceptance_rate": 74.4
    },
    "2015": {
     "accepted": 157,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 123,
     "dismissed": 14,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 280,
     "total": 294,
     "acceptance_rate": 56.1
    },
    "2016": {
     "accepted": 137,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 72,
     "dismissed": 16,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 209,
     "total": 225,
     "acceptance_rate": 65.6
    },
    "2017": {
     "accepted": 154,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 125,
     "dismissed": 31,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 279,
     "total": 310,
     "acceptance_rate": 55.2
    },
    "2018": {
     "accepted": 86,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 73,
     "dismissed": 18,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 159,
     "total": 177,
     "acceptance_rate": 54.1
    },
    "2019": {
     "accepted": 160,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 98,
     "dismissed": 9,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 1,
     "merit_total": 258,
     "total": 268,
     "acceptance_rate": 62.0
    },
    "2020": {
     "accepted": 97,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 53,
     "dismissed": 10,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 150,
     "total": 160,
     "acceptance_rate": 64.7
    },
    "2021": {
     "accepted": 105,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 112,
     "dismissed": 17,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 217,
     "total": 234,
     "acceptance_rate": 48.4
    },
    "2022": {
     "accepted": 142,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 134,
     "dismissed": 18,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 276,
     "total": 294,
     "acceptance_rate": 51.4
    },
    "2023": {
     "accepted": 144,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 119,
     "dismissed": 20,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 1,
     "merit_total": 263,
     "total": 284,
     "acceptance_rate": 54.8
    },
    "2024": {
     "accepted": 108,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 109,
     "dismissed": 21,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 217,
     "total": 238,
     "acceptance_rate": 49.8
    },
    "2025": {
     "accepted": 113,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 99,
     "dismissed": 18,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 212,
     "total": 230,
     "acceptance_rate": 53.3
    },
    "2026": {
     "accepted": 86,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 52,
     "dismissed": 11,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 138,
     "total": 149,
     "acceptance_rate": 62.3
    }
   },
   "by_case_type": {
    "거절결정불복": {
     "accepted": 463,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 52,
     "dismissed": 3,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 515,
     "total": 518,
     "acceptance_rate": 89.9
    },
    "디자인무효": {
     "accepted": 1167,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 915,
     "dismissed": 87,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 17,
     "merit_total": 2082,
     "total": 2186,
     "acceptance_rate": 56.1
    },
    "보정각하불복": {
     "accepted": 16,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 5,
     "dismissed": 2,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 21,
     "total": 23,
     "acceptance_rate": 76.2
    },
    "소극권리범위확인": {
     "accepted": 568,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 175,
     "dismissed": 35,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 1,
     "merit_total": 743,
     "total": 779,
     "acceptance_rate": 76.4
    },
    "적극권리범위확인": {
     "accepted": 425,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 558,
     "dismissed": 199,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 12,
     "merit_total": 983,
     "total": 1194,
     "acceptance_rate": 43.2
    },
    "취소결정불복": {
     "accepted": 10,
     "partially_accepted": 0,
     "rejected": 44,
     "dismissed": 3,
     "withdrawn": 0,
     "other": 0,
     "merit_total": 54,
     "total": 57,
     "acceptance_rate": 18.5
    }
   },
   "by_year_and_type": {
    "2010": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 53,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 56,
      "total": 57,
      "acceptance_rate": 94.6
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 109,
      "rejected": 31,
      "merit_total": 140,
      "total": 141,
      "acceptance_rate": 77.9
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 28,
      "rejected": 7,
      "merit_total": 35,
      "total": 39,
      "acceptance_rate": 80.0
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 21,
      "rejected": 31,
      "merit_total": 52,
      "total": 72,
      "acceptance_rate": 40.4
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 2,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 5,
      "total": 5,
      "acceptance_rate": 40.0
     }
    },
    "2011": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 42,
      "rejected": 4,
      "merit_total": 46,
      "total": 47,
      "acceptance_rate": 91.3
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 121,
      "rejected": 45,
      "merit_total": 166,
      "total": 180,
      "acceptance_rate": 72.9
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 43,
      "rejected": 23,
      "merit_total": 66,
      "total": 71,
      "acceptance_rate": 65.2
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 36,
      "rejected": 45,
      "merit_total": 81,
      "total": 103,
      "acceptance_rate": 44.4
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 3,
      "total": 3,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2012": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 48,
      "rejected": 4,
      "merit_total": 52,
      "total": 52,
      "acceptance_rate": 92.3
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 107,
      "rejected": 56,
      "merit_total": 163,
      "total": 168,
      "acceptance_rate": 65.6
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 33,
      "rejected": 12,
      "merit_total": 45,
      "total": 46,
      "acceptance_rate": 73.3
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 29,
      "rejected": 30,
      "merit_total": 59,
      "total": 73,
      "acceptance_rate": 49.2
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 6,
      "merit_total": 6,
      "total": 6,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2013": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 34,
      "rejected": 5,
      "merit_total": 39,
      "total": 39,
      "acceptance_rate": 87.2
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 76,
      "rejected": 70,
      "merit_total": 146,
      "total": 153,
      "acceptance_rate": 52.1
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 35,
      "rejected": 8,
      "merit_total": 43,
      "total": 46,
      "acceptance_rate": 81.4
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 35,
      "rejected": 39,
      "merit_total": 74,
      "total": 87,
      "acceptance_rate": 47.3
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 6,
      "merit_total": 6,
      "total": 7,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2014": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 60,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 62,
      "total": 62,
      "acceptance_rate": 96.8
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 101,
      "rejected": 39,
      "merit_total": 140,
      "total": 149,
      "acceptance_rate": 72.1
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 5,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 7,
      "total": 8,
      "acceptance_rate": 71.4
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 37,
      "rejected": 6,
      "merit_total": 43,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 86.0
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 21,
      "rejected": 27,
      "merit_total": 48,
      "total": 62,
      "acceptance_rate": 43.8
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2015": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 38,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 39,
      "total": 39,
      "acceptance_rate": 97.4
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 48,
      "rejected": 78,
      "merit_total": 126,
      "total": 126,
      "acceptance_rate": 38.1
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 4,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 5,
      "total": 6,
      "acceptance_rate": 80.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 32,
      "rejected": 13,
      "merit_total": 45,
      "total": 48,
      "acceptance_rate": 71.1
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 34,
      "rejected": 27,
      "merit_total": 61,
      "total": 71,
      "acceptance_rate": 55.7
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 4,
      "total": 4,
      "acceptance_rate": 25.0
     }
    },
    "2016": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 41,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 43,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 95.3
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 56,
      "rejected": 37,
      "merit_total": 93,
      "total": 105,
      "acceptance_rate": 60.2
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 2,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 3,
      "total": 3,
      "acceptance_rate": 66.7
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 22,
      "rejected": 14,
      "merit_total": 36,
      "total": 36,
      "acceptance_rate": 61.1
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 15,
      "rejected": 18,
      "merit_total": 33,
      "total": 37,
      "acceptance_rate": 45.5
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     }
    },
    "2017": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 38,
      "rejected": 5,
      "merit_total": 43,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 88.4
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 68,
      "rejected": 72,
      "merit_total": 140,
      "total": 152,
      "acceptance_rate": 48.6
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 22,
      "rejected": 9,
      "merit_total": 31,
      "total": 35,
      "acceptance_rate": 71.0
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 24,
      "rejected": 39,
      "merit_total": 63,
      "total": 78,
      "acceptance_rate": 38.1
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 2,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 2,
      "total": 2,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     }
    },
    "2018": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 16,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 19,
      "total": 20,
      "acceptance_rate": 84.2
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 36,
      "rejected": 37,
      "merit_total": 73,
      "total": 77,
      "acceptance_rate": 49.3
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 20,
      "rejected": 11,
      "merit_total": 31,
      "total": 35,
      "acceptance_rate": 64.5
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 12,
      "rejected": 22,
      "merit_total": 34,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 35.3
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 2,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 2,
      "total": 2,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     }
    },
    "2019": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 25,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 26,
      "total": 26,
      "acceptance_rate": 96.2
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 88,
      "rejected": 46,
      "merit_total": 134,
      "total": 138,
      "acceptance_rate": 65.7
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 27,
      "rejected": 19,
      "merit_total": 46,
      "total": 47,
      "acceptance_rate": 58.7
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 20,
      "rejected": 31,
      "merit_total": 51,
      "total": 56,
      "acceptance_rate": 39.2
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2020": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 16,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 16,
      "total": 16,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 37,
      "rejected": 25,
      "merit_total": 62,
      "total": 64,
      "acceptance_rate": 59.7
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 28,
      "rejected": 5,
      "merit_total": 33,
      "total": 34,
      "acceptance_rate": 84.8
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 16,
      "rejected": 20,
      "merit_total": 36,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 44.4
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 3,
      "total": 3,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2021": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 7,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 7,
      "total": 7,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 33,
      "rejected": 68,
      "merit_total": 101,
      "total": 106,
      "acceptance_rate": 32.7
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 28,
      "rejected": 11,
      "merit_total": 39,
      "total": 40,
      "acceptance_rate": 71.8
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 37,
      "rejected": 31,
      "merit_total": 68,
      "total": 79,
      "acceptance_rate": 54.4
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 2,
      "total": 2,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2022": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 24,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 27,
      "total": 27,
      "acceptance_rate": 88.9
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 44,
      "rejected": 67,
      "merit_total": 111,
      "total": 112,
      "acceptance_rate": 39.6
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 1,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 33,
      "rejected": 7,
      "merit_total": 40,
      "total": 43,
      "acceptance_rate": 82.5
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 40,
      "rejected": 54,
      "merit_total": 94,
      "total": 108,
      "acceptance_rate": 42.6
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 3,
      "total": 3,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2023": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 6,
      "rejected": 0,
      "merit_total": 6,
      "total": 6,
      "acceptance_rate": 100.0
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 56,
      "rejected": 72,
      "merit_total": 128,
      "total": 128,
      "acceptance_rate": 43.8
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 57,
      "rejected": 8,
      "merit_total": 65,
      "total": 71,
      "acceptance_rate": 87.7
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 25,
      "rejected": 39,
      "merit_total": 64,
      "total": 79,
      "acceptance_rate": 39.1
     }
    },
    "2024": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 9,
      "rejected": 12,
      "merit_total": 21,
      "total": 21,
      "acceptance_rate": 42.9
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 44,
      "rejected": 57,
      "merit_total": 101,
      "total": 109,
      "acceptance_rate": 43.6
     },
     "보정각하불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 1,
      "merit_total": 1,
      "total": 1,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 39,
      "rejected": 10,
      "merit_total": 49,
      "total": 49,
      "acceptance_rate": 79.6
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 16,
      "rejected": 26,
      "merit_total": 42,
      "total": 54,
      "acceptance_rate": 38.1
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 3,
      "merit_total": 3,
      "total": 4,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2025": {
     "거절결정불복": {
      "accepted": 6,
      "rejected": 7,
      "merit_total": 13,
      "total": 13,
      "acceptance_rate": 46.2
     },
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 47,
      "rejected": 43,
      "merit_total": 90,
      "total": 96,
      "acceptance_rate": 52.2
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 39,
      "rejected": 7,
      "merit_total": 46,
      "total": 46,
      "acceptance_rate": 84.8
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 21,
      "rejected": 34,
      "merit_total": 55,
      "total": 67,
      "acceptance_rate": 38.2
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 0,
      "rejected": 8,
      "merit_total": 8,
      "total": 8,
      "acceptance_rate": 0.0
     }
    },
    "2026": {
     "디자인무효": {
      "accepted": 52,
      "rejected": 31,
      "merit_total": 83,
      "total": 87,
      "acceptance_rate": 62.7
     },
     "소극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 24,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 26,
      "total": 26,
      "acceptance_rate": 92.3
     },
     "적극권리범위확인": {
      "accepted": 8,
      "rejected": 17,
      "merit_total": 25,
      "total": 31,
      "acceptance_rate": 32.0
     },
     "취소결정불복": {
      "accepted": 2,
      "rejected": 2,
      "merit_total": 4,
      "total": 5,
      "acceptance_rate": 50.0
     }
    }
   },
   "overall": {
    "accepted": 2649,
    "partially_accepted": 0,
    "rejected": 1749,
    "dismissed": 329,
    "withdrawn": 0,
    "other": 30,
    "merit_total": 4398,
    "total": 4757,
    "acceptance_rate": 60.2
   }
  }
 }
}